The Solo Traveller's View

David Garrett’s Strength and Weakness

16 Comments

An attempted Analysis of a Musical Phenomenon – Part 8

Particularly interesting is David Garrett’s description of what it meant to get his first Stradivari at age eleven, and the difficult position it put him in when he realised that its peculiar sound was not suited to his needs. This tells us how finely tuned his hearing must have been already in those early years; and that, at least in part, must have something to do with why he played so well from the beginning. Although they do not draw attention to themselves, those neat, unobtrusive ears of his are very important, because they are the gateway to David’s great strength: a remarkably subtle and accurate sense of hearing.

2011 Wetten, dass ... sharpened

He gave proof of it most notably on the programme ‘Wetten, dass…?’ on German TV in 2011, when he accepted a challenge to identify at least four out of five violins by their sound, as well as naming the corresponding violinist and conductor of each particular recording of Beethoven’s violin concerto (Op. 61). David knew this to be difficult, but was prepared to try it anyway. Four recordings were then played in turn, having been picked from a row of about 30, and David closed his eyes to listen with utter concentration. The audience listened too, but – needless to say – did not hear what he heard.

He did not need that fifth guess. It never took David long to identify the sound and to name the instrument, adding the year in which it was built for good measure. Regrettably, the camera does not always show his face at the exact moment when he becomes certain of which instrument he is hearing, though surely that is the point of interest.

86 Wetten dass 2011

That David Garrett was able to identify each violin and recording correctly seems all but impossible to us predominantly visual types. We are quite ready to suspect that it must be a hoax, a setup – were it not for the assurance of the host that they would never do such a thing, and for the fact that David’s manner is consistent with the challenge. His hands are cold with nervous tension and he voices uncertainty as to whether accepting this bet has been a good idea. After all, he could really make a fool of himself. Yet he goes on to prove beyond the shadows of doubt that his sense of hearing, as well as his knowledge of violins and Beethoven recordings, is advanced to a level few will reach.

Look at it like this: We are able to identify people we know by the sound of their voice, and it calls to mind what else we know about them, such as their age and who they like to hang out with. David Garrett just happens to be acquainted not only with people, but with an impressive number of violins as well, especially Stradivaris. He recognises their voice, their timbre, and knows them well enough to fill in their particulars.

Asked by an interviewer about being a soloist in a classical concert, David’s unexpected reply is that it begins with listening. Listening to the specific way the orchestra is playing that night, listening to the music, listening to the emotions the sound carries … He does listen a lot, and he listens very closely: to his own daily practice, to the playing of others, to all the words and sounds and songs that make up his world.

But if David Garrett’s sense of hearing is his strength, his visual sense is his weakness. You wouldn’t think so, would you? Not those stunning eyes, surely? There is so much light in them, such a lively look, and he expresses his views in such a clear-sighted way. One just assumes that his eyes must be as perfect as the rest of him. But this is not the case. Little asides in various interviews reveal that David’s eyesight has always been weak. It is a family trait: his father, brother and sister all wear glasses. Despite his blurry vision, David often refused to wear the chunky spectacles he was given as a child. These days he wears contact lenses because he has no faith in laser surgery and would rather not risk his already poor eyesight in an operation.

Furthermore, David’s eyes do not distinguish colour well, and that is why he prefers to wear black, white and grey. But he has stated in an interview that his favourite colour is blue, and a helpful chart (click link) illustrates the range of shades seen with his particular type of colour-blindness, referred to as RGB Achromatomaly, showing that blue and purple are in fact the only tones that come close to the original colours. Green and brown hold a pale middle ground, but the warm and vibrant tones of red, pink, orange and yellow are missing.

So David Garrett lives in a visually dimmed world. What we see as the shades of the rainbow, he must hear as the shades of sound; and so the weakness of one sense feeds the strength of the other. But, in recompense for being deprived of a colourful world, David has been gifted with incredible eyelashes. What a consolation prize! The spiky shadow they cast under the glare of the stage lights is as the cherry on top of an ensemble that already seems much too good to be true.

162 Air - Bach 2011

There is another point to consider: David’s poor eyesight would explain the problems with spelling he mentions in another interview, where he supposes that he might be dyslexic. There is room for doubt, because correct spelling is a skill that relies first and foremost on a strong visual memory, and this in turn relies on good vision.

Almost all children with a pronounced visual orientation connect easily with those little code signs we call letters, and this easy connection results in a good understanding of how (often illogical) combinations of letters relate to the sounds of language. In a way, faultless spelling could be seen as an approximate visual equivalent to David Garrett’s aural feat of identifying violins by the colour of their sound alone, for few achieve it. Case in point: Nikolaus Harnoncourt’s name is misspelt on the TV screen, seen above. Did you notice?

***

To be continued with David Garrett and the Girls. If you click ‘follow blog via email’ you won’t miss it. And please leave a comment below. I do appreciate your feedback, so please help me by recording those kind words you like to post on Twitter and Facebook on this site as well. Thank you!

(All photographs are screenshots drawn from YouTube, for the purpose of illustration only. I trust the authors will allow this use of their picture material. No copyright infringement is intended.) 

Advertisements

Author: Fabienne Wolf

writing solo traveller

16 thoughts on “David Garrett’s Strength and Weakness

  1. Dear Fabienne,
    I think the same way you do. I heard the stories about his bad eyes and so I think, he goes his way to a hearing world-sight. Children usually love the visual world more und David couldn’t find friends easily. Music is a really good home for him! I wish him many friends feeling, seeing and hearing like him.

  2. Uma matéria bem escrita de um assunto curioso e muito interessante de David, a sua deficiência visual. Interessante porque foco num ponto inquestionável e já comprovado científicamente, a falta ou a deficiência de um sentido, aguça o desenvolvimento de outro. Adorei querida Fabienne Wolf, e desde já espero a próxima matéria a ser abordada por você com muita ansiedade!

  3. Obrigada! Eu realmente desconhecia esta deficiência de David … fato este, que só o torna mais especial ainda!

  4. Very nice!

  5. Thank you very much for that article! It is so well done!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😊

  6. Thanks for this interesting article. Looking forward to reading more about our dear David. Regards 🙂

  7. Thank you so much for your insight into this magical musician, your insight helps give one a much more intimate view of a very talented musician. Thank you!

  8. Danke! Ein wunderschönes, feinfühliges Essay über einen wunderbaren Musiker und Menschen. Die Augen sind das Tor zur Seele sagt man und seine sprechen offen und ehrlich. Er kämpft gegen seine Schwächen an, die jeder Mensch hat, und macht so Stärken daraus. Sollte vielen ein Vorbild sein!

  9. Dear Fabienne! Thank you so much for taking the time to do this. Again, I see a lot of my thoughts captured in your writing so beautifully. Keep up the good work! We sure appreciate it!

  10. My dear new friends, please forgive that I no longer reply to each one of your comments with a personal thank you. All my limited writing time is now spent on future instalments of this series. It is my impression that you will approve and consider this time well spent – as indeed do I. But let me assure you that I read each one of your precious comments with grateful joy. Your responses mean a lot to me! I only just discovered that I can ‘like’ your comments with a little star, so I happily ‘liked’ my way through the list of your earlier contributions. Don’t be surprised by these delayed notifications, for when did my blog ever get comments before? And such heartwarming ones at that? With this note I would like to thank you for each and every one – and please, keep them coming! My love to you all.

  11. Thank you so much for your insightful, interesting, intelligent and thoughtful articles about my favourite violinist. You are fortunate indeed to walk in two worlds and be able to understand his words. I am also intrigued by your other chronicles and look forward to reading more.

  12. Another great insight into the life and times of this fantastic artist! I look forward to each new installment. Thanks so much for writing these posts that mirror our thoughts and feelings for David to a tee!

  13. Dear Fabienne, thank you! I was looking forward to the continuation of the story. You write very kindly about David, and this has an absolute response in my soul. Very grateful to you. Reading about his remarkable hearing and weak eyesight, I am imbued with a greater sense of warmth and respect for him. It’s not a static idol, but a living, wonderful person.

  14. Fabienne, once again, thank you very much for the article!!! I have to admit that I didn’t know about the achromatomaly problem of David. Marina is right, we miss a lot of information about him because of the German language… Here is the excerpt of the German tv show “Wetten dass ?” in 2011 https://goo.gl/ZhQvot, for those who haven’t watched it. I am looking forward to read your next article about David and the girls!!!

  15. Dear Fabienne, it’s always a beautiful surprise to find that you wrote another article on David. And they’re always so interesting! I also realize how much we miss about him by not understanding German. Too bad. But your commentaries are filling those empty spaces and it is also interesting to find out that even if I don’t understand his many German chats or speeches or interviews, instinctively I had the right impressions on what kind of person he is and how he behaves and what he thinks about music and many other things. And this is only due to the fact that he communicates so well through his body and voice and facial expressions, and he is so transparent and genuine, he doesn’t hide himself behind a mask, even if he could be totally allowed to do it. And I could go on, if only my knowledge of the English language would be better. Thank you Fab, and of course I can’t wait to read ‘DG and the girls’! 😉

  16. Am loving all your posts! Your descriptions are so tuned in to David’s world! Thank you. I look forward to each one.

Your comment:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s